How do R32, R143A and R410 refrigerants impact the environment in Malaysia?

Refrigerants like R32, R143A, and R410A play significant roles in Malaysia’s air conditioning and refrigeration sector. With the country’s hot and humid climate driving heavy demand for cooling systems, understanding the environmental impacts of these refrigerants is critical. Their effects are largely defined by factors such as Global Warming Potential (GWP), Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP), and energy efficiency. Malaysia, as part of global agreements like the Montreal Protocol and its Kigali Amendment, is working to phase out high-GWP and ozone-depleting refrigerants. Below is an in-depth analysis of how R32, R143A, and R410A impact the environment in Malaysia.

1. R32 (Difluoromethane)

R32 is a single-component hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerant increasingly adopted for residential and commercial air conditioning systems.

Environmental Impact

1. Global Warming Potential (GWP):

   • R32 has a GWP of 675, which is much lower compared to R410A (2,088) and R143A (4,470).

   • A lower GWP means that R32 has a smaller contribution to global warming if it leaks into the atmosphere.

2. Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP):

   • R32 has an ODP of 0, indicating it does not harm the ozone layer.

   • This makes it a safer alternative to older refrigerants like R22, which have been phased out in Malaysia due to their ozone-depleting effects.

3. Energy Efficiency:

   • Air conditioning systems using R32 are more energy-efficient compared to those using R410A.

   • In Malaysia’s high cooling-demand environment, R32-based systems consume less electricity, reducing reliance on fossil fuels and lowering carbon emissions from power generation.

   • Lower energy consumption also translates to cost savings for consumers.

4. Flammability:

   • R32 is classified as mildly flammable (A2L). While it requires careful handling and installation, the risks are manageable with proper technician training.

R32 in Malaysia

R32 is rapidly gaining popularity in Malaysia as manufacturers shift towards environmentally friendly solutions. Its lower GWP and energy efficiency align with the country’s climate goals to reduce carbon emissions. Leading air conditioning brands in Malaysia, such as Daikin, Panasonic, and Midea, are actively promoting R32 systems. The refrigerant’s adoption supports Malaysia’s transition to greener technologies as part of its Kigali Amendment commitments.

P.S. Do you require assistance servicing your air conditioner? The Aircond service company you can trust is us! Our aircond specialist has years of experience and can provide you with the professional air conditioner service repair

2. R143A (Trifluoroethane)

R143A is an HFC refrigerant primarily used in refrigerant blends like R404A and R507 for commercial and industrial refrigeration. Unlike R32 and R410A, it is rarely used in standalone air conditioning systems.

Environmental Impact

1. Global Warming Potential (GWP):

   • R143A has a GWP of 4,470, one of the highest among commonly used refrigerants.

   • Such a high GWP means that any leaks of R143A into the atmosphere result in significant contributions to global warming, making it a major environmental concern.

2. Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP):

   • R143A has an ODP of 0, so it does not damage the ozone layer.

   • However, its high GWP offsets this benefit, making it less sustainable compared to alternatives like R32.

3. Energy Efficiency:

   • R143A is generally used in low-temperature refrigeration systems rather than air conditioners.

   • When used in refrigerant blends, it provides adequate performance, but it is less energy-efficient compared to newer alternatives.

4. Leakage Risks:

   • Industrial refrigeration systems in Malaysia, such as those used in supermarkets, cold storage facilities, and manufacturing plants, can suffer from refrigerant leaks.

   • Due to its high GWP, R143A leaks have a more severe impact on Malaysia’s carbon footprint.

R143A in Malaysia

R143A is limited to commercial refrigeration and industrial applications, where it serves as part of refrigerant blends. As Malaysia phases down high-GWP refrigerants, industries relying on R143A are being encouraged to adopt low-GWP alternatives. While R143A is not widely used in households, its significant impact on global warming makes it a target for replacement in Malaysia’s sustainability roadmap.

3. R410A

R410A is a widely used HFC refrigerant composed of a blend of R32 and R125. It was introduced as a replacement for ozone-depleting refrigerants like R22.

Environmental Impact

1. Global Warming Potential (GWP):

   • R410A has a GWP of 2,088, which is higher than R32 but lower than R143A.

   • When leaked, R410A significantly contributes to global warming, making it a less sustainable option for long-term use.

2. Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP):

   • R410A has an ODP of 0, meaning it does not harm the ozone layer.

   • Its adoption marked a major improvement over R22, which had an ozone depletion effect.

3. Energy Efficiency:

   • R410A systems are less energy-efficient compared to R32 systems.

   • In Malaysia’s tropical climate, air conditioners using R410A require more electricity to achieve the same cooling effect.

   • Higher energy consumption increases the country’s carbon emissions, especially since Malaysia’s power generation still relies on fossil fuels.

4. Adoption and Replacement:

   • While R410A remains common in older systems, manufacturers are phasing it out in favor of R32 due to its lower GWP and higher efficiency.

R410A in Malaysia

R410A has been widely used in Malaysian households and offices for years. However, its higher GWP and energy consumption make it unsustainable for the future. The Malaysian government and major manufacturers are actively encouraging consumers to shift to R32-based air conditioners as part of a broader eco-friendly initiative.

Related post: Can energy-efficient air conditioners reduce Malaysia’s carbon footprint?

Conclusion

In Malaysia, where air conditioning demand continues to grow, the environmental impact of refrigerants is a major concern. The comparison of R32, R143A, and R410A highlights the following:

1. R32 is the most sustainable option due to its low GWP, high energy efficiency, and zero ozone depletion potential. It is widely adopted in residential and commercial systems and aligns with Malaysia’s climate goals.

2. R143A has a very high GWP and is mostly used in industrial refrigeration. While it does not harm the ozone layer, its long-term sustainability is questionable, and efforts are needed to replace it with lower-GWP alternatives.

3. R410A has a moderate GWP but is being phased out due to its lower efficiency compared to R32. Its continued use increases carbon emissions, particularly in energy-intensive regions like Malaysia.

As Malaysia works to achieve its commitments under the Kigali Amendment and reduce its carbon footprint, adopting low-GWP refrigerants like R32 and exploring alternatives will be key to balancing cooling needs with environmental responsibility.